dotcom logo
Home


Green Bay
News-Chronicle

barbarbarbarbarend
Northeast
Wisconsin's
Internet monthly

Monday, May 13, 2002

internet law

Stations to pay
fees for Internet broadcasting

By Matt Richtel
New York Times

Radio stations that make their broadcasts available on the Internet must pay fees to record companies, the U.S. Copyright Office has ruled, in a decision that the radio stations assert conflicts with federal law.

The ruling, to be published on Monday, does not specify how much the fees are or when the radio stations must start paying them. But it does lend clarity to a several-year-old dispute over whether federally licensed radio stations that put their programming on the Internet are subject to the same "performance rights" fees as Internet-only radio stations.

And it provides a victory both to Internet-only radio stations seeking to compete against traditional stations, and to the record companies. As part of an overall strategy to cope with dramatic changes to the music industry brought on by the Internet, the record companies have lobbied for the fees to cover traditional radio stations.

Presently, record companies collect fees from several hundred Internet-only radio stations - which create programming exclusively for online distribution - said Hilary Rosen, president of the Recording Industry Association of America, which represents record companies. Rosen declined to disclose the levels of the fees, adding that the organization "looks forward" to negotiating rates with the traditional broadcasters.

Should the negotiations fail, the Copyright Office ruling sets a timetable for arbitration that will determine the amount of fees to be paid not just by traditional radio stations but also by thousands of Internet-only radio stations that have not yet reached deals with the record companies, people within the industry said.

All stations must pay royalties to composers and performers. Under a 1995 law, licensing fees are also due to copyright holders, such as record companies, when their works are distributed in a "digital audio" format.

However, the National Association of Broadcasters, a radio industry lobbying group, asserts that the federally licensed stations are exempt from paying such fees.

The group contends that, under federal law, radio stations do not have to pay fees to record labels when they broadcast over the airwaves and that such an exemption also covers the simultaneous broadcast of the same programming over the Internet.

Earlier this year, as the dispute took shape, the National Association of Broadcasters sued in U.S. District Court in New York asking the court to declare that broadcasters are indeed exempt from the fees. The court has yet to render an opinion.

Edward O. Fritts, president and chief executive of the trade association, said that the decision by the Copyright Office would force traditional radio stations to pay costs that their business plans had not accounted for. "They are trying to impose new fees on existing businesses," he said.

"This ruling is directly contrary to existing federal law," Fritts said in a statement. "That's why NAB has asked a federal district court in New York to settle the issue."

Meanwhile, members of the Internet-only radio industry hailed the ruling. Jonathan Potter, executive director of the Digital Media Association, a trade group representing Internet music and media companies, said the ruling would make it easier for the tens of thousands of companies that create radio for the Internet to compete against traditional radio stations.

"The decision ensures a level playing field between Broadcasters and Web-casters," he said.

Business directory

Advertising

Apartments

Auto dealers

Automotive parts

Automotive search

Business opportunity

Chiropractor & relaxation

Computers & repair

Computer training

Education

Employment

Event tickets and tours

Gardening centers

Grocers

Homebuilders

Hospitals

Hotels

Legal services

Mortgage banker

Natural health

Photography

Packer merchandise

Performances

Realtors

Restaurants

Shopping

Slides

Technology solutions

Tires

Upcoming event

 

Dot Com Northeast Wisconsin's Internet Monthly, is a publication of
The Green Bay News-Chronicle.
All content © copyright 2000 Green Bay News-Chronicle
and may not be republished without permission.